ECJ 10 May 2011 (Grand Chamber), case C-147/08 (Jürgen Römer – v – Freie und Hansestadt Hamburg), Sexual orientation discrimination
The supplementary pensions at issue constitute “pay” within the meaning of Article 157 TFEU and do not fall outside the material scope of the Directive.
The Directive precludes national law such as the Tax Provision if certain conditions are satisfied (see above).
If the Tax Provision is discriminatory, Mr Römer can claim equal treatment under the Directive, but not for the period before 3 December 2003.
European Court of Justice (ECJ), 2011-05-10